Team Honors
NCAA Appearances (25)
1984, 1985, 1986, 1987, 1988, 1989, 1990, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2011, 2015
CAA Championships (10)
1993, 1994, 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2003, 2011
ECAC Champions
1983
WAGS Champions
1987
Regional Rating Board Winners
1988, 1989, 1990
Coaches Association Academic Team Award (18)
2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020
NSCAA Team Ethics Award
2005, 2006, 2007 (bronze), 2009 (gold), 2010 (silver), 2012 (gold), 2014 (silver) 2015 (bronze)
The Flat Hat Team of the Year
2007-08
___________________________________________________________________________
National Honors
Hermann Trophy Watch List
2012
- Mallory Schaffer (Preseason)
2011
- Mallory Schaffer (Semifinal)
2008
- Dani Collins (Preseason)
- Claire Zimmeck (Semifinal)
2007
- Dani Collins (Preseason)
- Claire Zimmeck (Semifinal)
U.S. National Team
2021
- Erica Walsh (Asst. Coach)
2014-19
- Jill Ellis (Head Coach)
2008
- Jill Ellis (Asst. Coach)
- Erica Walsh (Asst. Coach)
1998
- Ann Cook
- Natalie Neaton
U.S. U-21 National Team
2006 - Dani Collins
Romania National Team
2020 - Alex Kuhnle
ISAA/NSCAA Player of the Year
1995 - Natalie Neaton
1987 - Megan McCarthy
NSCAA All-America (Team)
2015
- Caroline Casey (1)
2012
- Mallory Schaffer (2)
2011
- Mallory Schaffer (1)
2008
- Claire Zimmeck (2)
- Dani Collins (3)
2007
- Dani Collins (3)
- Claire Zimmeck (3)
1999
- Missy Wycinsky (2)
1998
- Missy Wycinsky (2)
- Stephanie Loehr (HM)
1997
- Ann Cook (1)
- Missy Wycinsky (3)
1995
- Natalie Neaton (2)
- Ann Cook (3)
1994
- Natalie Neaton (1)
1993
- Ann Cook (2)
- Natalie Neaton (2)
1992
- Rebecca Wakefield (1)
- Natalie Neaton (2)
1991
- Erin McGonegal (2)
1990
- Robin Lotze (1)
- Sandra Gaskill (1)
1989
- Robin Lotze (1)
1988
- Robin Lotze (2)
1987
- Megan McCarthy (1)
- Julie Cunningham (1)
- Jill Ellis (3)
1986
- Megan McCarthy (1)
- Julie Cunningham (2)
1985
- Megan McCarthy (1)
- Julie Cunningham (2)
Soccer America All-America (Team)
2011 - Mallory Schaffer (2)
1997 - Ann Cook (1)
1994 - Natalie Neaton (1)
1989 - Robin Lotze (1)
Soccer Buzz All-America (Team)
2008
- Claire Zimmeck (3)
2007
- Claire Zimmeck (3)
2006
- Claire Zimmeck (4)
1999
- Missy Wycinsky (2)
1998
- Stephanie Loehr (2)
- Missy Wycinsky (3)
1997
- Ann Cook (1)
- Missy Wycinsky (3)
Top Drawer Soccer Team of the Season
2008 - Abby Lauer (3)
2007 - Claire Zimmeck (1)
2006 - Claire Zimmeck (2)
Academic All-America
2012
- Mallory Schaffer
2011
- Mallory Schaffer
2008
- Dani Collins
- Abby Lauer
2006
- Anna Young
2003
- Tara Flint
- Nikki Villott
2002
- Tara Flint
- Franny Swajkoski
2001
- Janet Sury
1992
- Kris Fisher
1990
- Robin Lotze
1989
- Robin Lotze
1988
- Robin Lotze
Senior Class Award
2015
- Caroline Casey (Finalist/1st Team Senior Class All-American)
2012
- Mallory Schaffer (Finalist)
W&M Athletics Hall of Fame
2020 - Claire Zimmeck '09
2019 - 1997 Women's Soccer Team
2017 - Sandra Gaskill '91
2016 - Lindsey Vanderspiegel Martin '04
2014 - Carrie Moore '00
2011 - Missy Wycinsky-Pruden '00
2010 - Erica Walsh '97
2009 - Ann Cook '97
2007 - Natalie Neaton '96
2006 - Rebecca Wakefield '94
2003 - Robin Lotze Frolich '91
2002 - Jill Ellis '88
2000 - Julie Cunningham Shackford '88
1999 - Megan McCarthy '88
1978 - Agnes Winn Paschall '31
Phi Beta Kappa
2012 - Carson Scott & Jackie Blake-Hedges
2011 - Brittany Lane
2002 - Franny Swajkoski
1990 - Robin Lotze
Top Drawer Soccer Freshmen All-America (Team)
2010 - Audrey Barry (2)
Soccer America All-Rookie Team
2000 - Lindsey Vanderspiegel
1993 - Ann Cook
1992 - Natalie Neaton
1989 - Erin McGonegal
1984 - Megan McCarthy (Co-Rookie of the Year)
Soccer Buzz Freshman All-America
2008 - Diana Weigel (2)
2007 - Kaitlin O'Connor (2)
2000 - Lindsay Vanderspiegel (2)
1999 - Chanda Sneed (HM)
1997 - Kim Newell (2)
___________________________________________________________________________
Regional Honors
Regional Coach of the Year
- John Daly - 1989, 1990, 1992, 1997, 1999, 2006, 2011
- John Charles - 1983
NSCAA All-Region
2016
- Rachel Moore (3)
2015
- Nicole Baxter (1)
- Caroline Casey (1)
- Rachel Moore (3)
2014
- Emory Camper (3)
2013
- Caroline Casey (2)
2012
- Mallory Schaffer (1)
- Kiersten Harpe (2)
- Cortlyn Bristol (2)
2011
- Cortlyn Bristol (1)
- Mallory Schaffer (1)
- Diana Weigel (1)
2010
- Diana Weigel (2)
- Mallory Schaffer (3)
2008
- Claire Zimmeck (1)
- Dani Collins (1)
2007
- Claire Zimmeck (1)
- Meghan Walker (1)
- Dani Collins (1)
2006
- Claire Zimmeck (1)
- Dani Collins (1)
2003
- Taline Tahmassian (3)
2002
- Lindsey Vanderspiegel (1)
- Tara Flint (2)
Soccer Buzz All-Region
2008
- Claire Zimmeck (1)
- Dani Collins (1)
- Abby Lauer (3)
2007
- Claire Zimmeck (1)
- Dani Collins (1)
- Abby Lauer (2)
2006
- Claire Zimeck (1)
- Katie Hogwood (2)
- Dani Collins (2)
2005
- Anna Young (3)
2004
- Katie Hogwood (3)
All-Region
2001
- Tara Flint
- Lindsey Vanderspiegel
2000
- Jordan Krieger
- Kim Newell
- Lindsey Vanderspiegel
1999
- Michelle Horbaly
- Carrie Moore
- Lindsay Nohl
- Missy Wycinsky
1998
- Stephanie Loehr
- Carrie Moore
- Missy Wycinsky
1997
- Ann Cook
- Stephanie Loehr
- Missy Wycinsky
1996
- Erica Walsh
- Missy Wycinsky
1995
- Ann Cook
- Stephanie Loehr
- Natalie Neaton
1994
- Ann Cook
- Natalie Neaton
1993
- Ann Cook
- Natalie Neaton
- Maren Rojas
1992
- Natalie Neaton
- Maren Rojas
- Rebecca Wakefield
1991
- Erin McGonegal
- Peggy Melanson
1990
- Peggy Melanson
1989
- Kathy Carter
- Sandra Gaskill
- Peggy Melanson
- Rebecca Wakefield
1988
- Rebecca Wakefield
1987
- Robin Lotze (HM)
1985
- Julie Cunningham
- Megan McCarthy
- Jill Ellis (HM)
1984
- Julie Cunningham
- Megan McCarthy
1983
- Diann Szczypinski
Soccer Buzz Regional All-Freshman Team
2008
- Diana Weigel
2007
- Kaitlin O'Connor
- Katy Winsper
2006
- Krissy Vornadore
2005
- Claire Zimmeck
2004
- Brittany Bode
2003
- Katie Hogwood
2000
- Tara Flint
- Lindsay Vanderspiegel
1999
- Chanda Sneed
1997
- Kim Newell
CoSIDA Academic All-District
2023
- Kenna Zier
- Ginny Delacruz
- Nora Green-Orset
- Mia Suchora
- Jillian O'Toole
- Leah Iglesias
2022
- Emma D'Alesandro
- Ginny Delacruz
- Bridget Fitzpatrick
- Elaina Longjohn
- Addie Puskar
- Jillian O'Toole
2015
- Leci Irvin
- Samantha Cordum
2011
- Mallory Schaffer
2007
- Abby Lauer
2006
- Dani Collins
- Anna Young
- Abby Lauer
VaSID Coach of the Year
John Daly - 1994, 1998, 1999, 2006, 2011
VaSID Player of the Year
2011 - Mallory Schaffer
2006 - Claire Zimmeck
VaSID All-State Team
2021
- Zoe Doughty (1)
2021 Spring
- Erin Dailey (2)
2018
- Sarah Segan (2)
2017
- Elysse Branton (1)
- Rachel Moore (1)
- Sarah Segan (1)
2016
- Clara Logsdon (1)
- Rachel Moore (2)
- Sarah Segan (2)
2015
- Nicole Baxter (1)
- Caroline Casey (1)
- Clara Logsdon (1)
- Leci Irvin (2)
- Katie Johnston (2)
- Rachel Moore (2)
2014
- Emory Camper (2)
2013
- Emory Camper (1)
2012
- Kiersten Harpe (1)
- Mallory Schaffer (1)
- Cortlyn Bristol (2)
2011
- Mallory Schaffer (1)
- Emory Camper (1)
- Diana Weigel (1)
- Cortlyn Bristol (2)
- Dani Rutter (2)
2009
- Diana Weigel (1)
2008
- Claire Zimmeck (1)
- Dani Collins (1)
- Abby Lauer (1)
- Meghan Walker (1)
2007
- Claire Zimmeck (1)
- Dani Collins (1)
- Kaitlin O'Connor (1)
- Abby Lauer (2)
- Meghan Walker (2)
- Emily Kittleson (2)
2006
- Claire Zimmeck (1)
- Dani Collins (1)
- Meghan Walker (1)
- Anna Young (2)
- Donna Mataya (2)
- Abby Lauer (2)
2005
- Claire Zimmeck (2)
W&M AEF Award
1999 - Missy Wycinsky
1998 - Stephanie Loehr
1996 - Natalie Neaton
___________________________________________________________________________
CAA Honors
CAA Coach of the Year
- John Daly - 1993, 1994, 1999, 2006, 2011
CAA Player of the Year
2012 - Mallory Schaffer
2011 - Mallory Schaffer
2007 - Claire Zimmeck
2006 - Claire Zimmeck
2002 - Lindsey Vanderspiegel
2001 - Tara Flint
2000 - Jordan Krieger
1999 - Missy Wycinsky
1998 - Missy Wycinsky
1997 - Ann Cook
1995 - Natalie Neaton
1993 - Natalie Neaton
CAA Defender of the Year
2016 - Clara Logsdon (co-)
2015 - Caroline Casey
2009 - Diana Weigel
2008 - Abby Lauer (co-)
1999 - Stephanie Loehr
CAA Goalkeeper of the Year
2021 - Zoe Doughty
CAA Preseason Player of the Year
2012 - Mallory Schaffer
2008 - Claire Zimmeck
2007 - Claire Zimmeck (co-)
CAA Scholar-Athlete of the Year
2012 - Mallory Schaffer
2011 - Mallory Schaffer
2008 - Abby Lauer
CAA Rookie of the Year
2022 - Ivey Crain
2003 - Katie Hogwood (co-)
2000 - Lindsey Vanderspiegel
1995 - Mary Totman
CAA Tournament MVP
2011 - Tara Connors
2003 - Nikki Villott
2001 - Lindsey Vanderspiegel
2000 - Kim Newell
1999 - Missy Wycinsky
1998 - Whitney Paynter
1997 - Ann Cook
1996 - Whitney Paynter
All-CAA
2024
Ivey Crain (2)
2023
Nicole Sellers (1)
Ivey Crain (2)
2022
Ivey Crain (1)
2021
Zoe Doughty (1)
2021 spring
Erin Dailey (2)
Lauren Kelly (2)
2019
Renee Kohler (2)
Sarah Segan (3)
2018
Sarah Segan (1)
Lauren Kelly (3)
2017
Elysse Branton (1)
Rachel Moore (1)
Sarah Segan (2)
2016
Clara Logsdon (1)
Rachel Moore (1)
Sarah Segan (2)
Elysse Branton (3)
Haley Kent (3)
2015
Nicole Baxter (1)
Caroline Casey (1)
Clara Logsdon (1)
Rachel Moore (2)
Samantha Cordum (3)
Leci Irvin (3)
Katie Johnston (3)
Sami Grasso (3)
2014
Emory Camper (2)
Samantha Cordum (2)
Emily Fredrikson (2)
Rachel Moore (2)
Caroline Casey (3)
2013
Caroline Casey (1)
Emory Camper (1)
Emily Fredrikson (2)
Taylor Dyson (3)
Dani Rutter (3)
2012
Cortlyn Bristol (1)
Kiersten Harpe (1)
Mallory Schaffer (1)
Emily Fredrikson (2)
Dani Rutter (2)
2011
Cortlyn Bristol (1)
Mallory Schaffer (1)
Diana Weigel (1)
Emily Fredrikson (2)
2010
Mallory Schaffer (1)
Diana Weigel (1)
Cortlyn Bristol (2)
Audrey Barry (3)
2009
Diana Weigel (1)
Krissy Vornadore (2)
Kaitlin O'Connor (3)
2008
Claire Zimmeck (1)
Dani Collins (1)
Abby Lauer (1)
Meghan Walker (1)
Kaitlin O'Connor (3)
2007
Claire Zimmeck (1)
Dani Collins (1)
Kaitlin O'Connor (1)
Meghan Walker (2)
Abby Lauer (3)
2006
Claire Zimmeck (1)
Dani Collins (1)
Meghan Walker (2)
Anna Young (2)
Katie Hogwood (2)
2005
Anna Young (2)
Claire Zimmeck (2)
Lydia Sturgis (2)
2004
Katie Hogwood (1)
Taline Tahmassian (2)
2003
Lindsay Vanderspiegel (1)
Taline Tahmassian (1)
2002
Lindsay Vanderspiegel (1)
Tara Flint (1)
Lydia Sturgis (2)
Taline Tahmassian (2)
Franny Swajkoski (2)
2001
Tara Flint (1)
Lindsay Vanderspiegel (1)
Jordan Krieger (2)
Lara Pawlow (2)
Janet Sury (2)
Franny Swajkoski (2)
2000
Jordan Krieger (1)
Kim Newell (1)
Lindsay Vanderspiegel (1)
Tara Flint (2)
Franny Swajkoski (2)
1999
Michelle Horbaly (1)
Carrie Moore (1)
Kim Newell (1)
Lindsay Nohl (1)
Missy Wycinsky (1)
Jordan Krieger (2)
Avery Willis (2)
1998
Stephanie Loehr (1)
Carrie Moore (1)
Missy Wycinsky (1)
Kim Newell (2)
1997
Ann Cook (1)
Stephanie Loehr (1)
Missy Wycinsky (1)
Carrie Moore (2)
Janet Sury (2)
1996
Carrie Moore (1)
Erica Walsh (1)
Missy Wycinsky (1)
Lindsay Nohl (2)
1995
Ann Cook (1)
Stephanie Loehr (1)
Natalie Neaton
Mary Totman (1) (1)
Erica Walsh (1)
Whitney Cali (2)
1994
Jenn Baumann (1)
Ann Cook (1)
Stephanie Loehr (1)
Natalie Neaton (1)
Kelcey Becker (2)
Susie Metzger (2)
1993
Jenn Baumann (1)
Ann Cook (1)
Julie DiRenzo (1)
Natalie Neaton (1)
Maren Rojas (HM)
CAA All-Rookie Team
2024
Peyton Costello
2023
Molly Widderich
2022
Ivey Crain
2021
Riley Friesen
2018
Grace Santos
2016
Sarah Segan
2015
Mackenzie Kober
2014
Elysse Branton
Rachel Moore
2013
Clara Logsdon
2012
Nicole Baxter
Caroline Casey
Leci Irvin
Barbara Platenberg
2011
Emory Camper
Emily Fredrikson
2010
Audrey Barry
2009
Cortlyn Bristol
2008
Diana Weigel
2007
Kaitlin O'Connor
Katy Winsper
2006
- Krissy Vornadore
2005
Dani Collins
Claire Zimmeck
2004
Brittany Bode
Mary MacKenzie Grier
CAA All-Tournament Team
2017
Elysse Branton
Erin Dailey
2016
Corinne Giroux
Samantha Johnson
2015
Elysse Branton
Haley Kent
Meghan Musgrove
2014
Leci Irvin
Katie Johnston
2013
Ali Heck
Dani Rutter
2012
Kiersten Harpe
Leci irvin
2011
Tara Connors
Dani Rutter
Aly Shaughnessy
Katherine Yount
2008
Dani Collins
Claire Zimmeck
2007
Meghan Walker
Mary MacKenzie Grier
2006
Lauren Bowers
Donna Mataya
2004
Mary MacKenzie Grier
Shannon Mosier
Taline Tahmassian
2003
Tara Flint
Susanne Huntington
Nikki Villott
Anna Young
2002
Lindsay Vanderspiegel
Nikki Villott
2001
Jordan Krieger
Franny Swajkoski
Lindsay Vanderspiegel
2000
Tara Flint
Kim Newell
Franny Swajkoski
Lindsay Vanderspiegel
1999
- Michelle Horbaly
- Kristin Ryan
- Chanda Sneed
- Franny Swajkoski
- Missy Wycinski
1998
Jordan Krieger
Stephanie Loehr
Carrie Moore
Whitney Paynter
Kristin Ryan
CAA Pre-Season Team
2024
Ivey Crain
2023
Ivey Crain
2022
Zoe Doughty
2019
Sarah Segan
2018
Sarah Segan
2017
Elysse Branton
Rachel Moore
Sarah Segan
Haley Kent (HM)
Mackenzie Kober (HM)
2016
Clara Logsdon
Rachel Moore
Elysse Branton (HM)
Sami Grasso (HM)
2015
Caroline Casey
Leci Irvin
Elysse Branton (HM)
Rachel Moore (HM)
2014
Emory Camper
Caroline Casey
Emily Fredrickson
2013
Dani Rutter
Emily Fredrikson
Leci Irvin (HM)
2012
Cortlyn Bristol
Mallory Schaffer
Emily Fredrikson
Emory Camper (HM)
2011
Audrey Barry
Cortlyn Bristol
Mallory Schaffer
Diana Weigel
2010
Diana Weigel
Kaitlin O'Connor (HM)
2008
Claire Zimmeck
Dani Collins
Kaitlin O'Conner
Meghan Walker
2007
Dani Collins
Claire Zimmeck
Â
